THRIFTYFLIPPER

Video Game Value Checker PRO

Free video game value checker Specialist Guide

hello@thriftyflipper.com

Flipper's Knowledge Bank

It depends on the title, and the gap is the whole trade. Guides price loose, complete, box only and manual only separately. On Rule of Rose the loose disc was tracked at $713.38 and complete at $1,072.09, so box and manual add half the value again. Price the row matching the copy in your hand.

No. The game still plays. You lose the old saves and the ability to write new ones until the coin cell is replaced, Buyers treat a disclosed dead battery as a known defect with a cheap repair, not a write off.

No. PlayStation and PlayStation 2 discs are region locked into NTSC-U/C, NTSC-J and PAL. PlayStation 3, 4 and 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series and Nintendo Switch are not region locked, so those imports boot normally.

Usually yes, and the sealed market shows it hardest. Sealed Final Fantasy VII black label tracked at $1,406.84 against $164.20 for the Greatest Hits printing, while loose copies of both sat within a few dollars of each other. Check the band on the art and the SLUS or SLES prefix on the disc.

What is a good sell-through rate?

A sell-through rate (STR) measures how fast items sell. A good rule of thumb for beginners is to look for items with at least a 50% STR, meaning there are as many sold listings as active listings in the last 90 days.

How to check eBay comps?

  1. Filter by "Sold Items" and "Completed Items".
  2. Sort by "Recent" to see the current market value.
  3. Ignore active prices; only sold prices matter.

Essentials for beginners?

  • Polymailers: Cheap and great for clothing.
  • Bubble Wrap: Essential for breakables.
  • Shipping Tape: Don't use regular scotch tape.

How to weigh packages?

Always weigh your package after it is fully packed. Use a digital scale and round up. Incorrect weights lead to postage adjustments.

What does BOLO mean?

BOLO stands for "Be On The Look Out". It refers to items or brands that are currently high-profit or fast-selling.

Best places to source?

  • Thrift Stores (Goodwill, Savers)
  • Garage/Yard Sales (Lowest prices)
  • Estate Sales (High quality vintage)
  • Media Mail: Cheapest for Books, CDs, DVDs.
  • PirateShip: Never pay post office retail. Use PirateShip.com for commercial rates.
  • Poly Mailers: Don't box clothing. Bag it to keep weight under 1lb.

When scanning books, always check Amazon. Look at the "Best Sellers Rank".


Rule of Thumb:

  • Rank under 1,000,000 = Sells eventually.
  • Rank under 100,000 = Sells very fast.

The Google button is your safety net. Use it to check Retail Prices. If you find a "rare" toy for $10, check Google to make sure Target isn't selling it brand new for $12.

  • UPC-A & UPC-E (Standard Retail)
  • EAN-13 & EAN-8 (International)
  • ISBN (Books & Media)

© 2026 ThriftyFlipper. Global Arbitrage Scout.

PRO-GRADE SCANNER

Access live eBay Sold prices, Amazon comps, and market data instantly.

Free Video Game Value Checker, Retro & Modern Price Scanner (2026)

Video Game Value Checker

What sets the price: the copy, not the title

A game's price is not a property of the title. It is a property of the copy in your hand. Two copies of Silent Hill 2 on PlayStation 2 on one thrift shelf were $134.14 and $947.50 apart on 2026-09-28, and the difference was nothing but condition: loose $134.14, complete $201.24, sealed $947.50.

Scan for the ballpark, then work out which copy you are holding. Most bad game buys are condition mistakes, not title mistakes.

Games carry condition rules the other categories do not. The sold-listing discipline matches a book scanning app on an ISBN run or a shoe reseller price checker on a sneaker wall, but on games it lands on discs, cartridges, save batteries and region codes. Six things drive price: print run, completeness, battery state, disc surface, region, print edition. Only one is about the game itself.

Disc or cartridge: two different failure modes

Cartridges and discs die in opposite ways.

Cartridge era games shipped in cardboard boxes buyers threw away, so loose carts dominate the surviving supply and the box carries its own price. The cart rarely stops working; it fails at the save battery and at label damage.

Disc era cases survive, so a case alone is not a value driver on a PlayStation 2 or GameCube title. What kills disc era value is the surface: deep scratches, a resurfacing history, cracks. On carts you inspect paper and labels; on discs you tilt the reflective side under a light and look for scratches crossing the data tracks.

The condition ladder, priced

Price guides do not price a game once. They price every state of it separately. Rule of Rose on PlayStation 2, read live on PriceCharting, a sold-price guide covering about 45,000 games, on 2026-09-28:

What you are holdingLive priceWhat it tells you
Loose, disc only$713.38The floor for this title
Disc and box$892.74The original case adds about $179
Disc and manual$893.00The manual adds about $180
Complete$1,072.09Box and manual stack on top of each other
Sealed$1,400.83Sealed is its own market
Box only$202.50People buy parts
Manual only$274.68A manual alone is a real product
Graded complete$901.50Grading does not beat a clean complete copy here
Graded sealed$1,482.00Grading pays on sealed copies of scarce titles

Read the parts rows first. A manual alone prices at $274.68 against a $713.38 loose disc, so a bin copy hiding a manual is real money and a missing manual is a real deduction. Grading did not create value here either; it repriced a copy already near the top of the ladder. PriceCharting is free, with a Collector tier at $6 a month and a Legendary tier at $49 a month for API access.

First print versus Greatest Hits and the other reissue lines

Publishers reprinted best sellers as budget lines: Greatest Hits from Sony, Player's Choice from Nintendo, later Nintendo Selects, and Platinum Hits from Microsoft. On PlayStation 2 the reissue swapped the black spine trim for a red band, which is where the term black label comes from for the original release.

The disc inside a reissue is the same game. The printing is the product, and the reissue runs were far larger. Final Fantasy VII on PlayStation, read live on 2026-09-28:

VersionLooseCompleteSealed
Black label first print$24.99$56.40$1,406.84
Greatest Hits reissue$16.85$33.04$164.20

Loose prices sit within a few dollars of each other because a loose disc plays the same either way. The gap opens with the case and explodes when sealed: roughly eight times the price for the same game, decided entirely by which printing it is.

Two checks catch it. First the band: reissue art carries a distinguishing stripe, red on later Sony lines and green on the original PlayStation Greatest Hits. Second the serial: Sony's North American discs use SLUS and SCUS prefixes and PAL discs use SLES and SCES, so a serial that does not match the case is a married set and prices like one. A few reissues are enhanced editions rather than plain reprints, so check the title.

Cartridge save batteries: test before you price

Most NES, Super NES, Nintendo 64, Game Boy and Game Boy Color cartridges hold saves in SRAM kept alive by a CR2032 coin cell. Those cells typically last 10 to 20 years, which puts most of the era past due. A dead cell does not stop the game playing; it stops the game saving. Old files are gone and nothing new writes until the cell is replaced.

Boot every cartridge before you price it: start a new file, save, reload and confirm the save is there. Disclosed dead batteries price as known deductions, not shocks.

Game Boy Advance carts are their own case, and this is where Pokemon sellers get caught. Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald carry a small CR1616 cell that powers a real time clock, not the save, which lives elsewhere on the board. When the cell dies the game says so on startup: "The internal battery has run dry. The game can be played. However, clock-based events will no longer occur." The save survives, berry growth and tide events do not, and a fresh cell does not restore clock events to a save that already exists. Disclose it or eat the return.

Discs: scratches and resurfacing as a paid service

Resurfacing is a real, openly priced retail service. Planet Retro Video Games in Pennsylvania, read live on 2026-09-28, charges $4 per disc plus flat $5 return shipping on mail-ins and runs ELM USA machines, including an ECO-Master batch unit rated at 50 discs per cycle and an ECO-Auto Smart single disc unit. The same page states the limit: resurfacing cannot recover a disc when damage reaches the data layer, or when it is cracked, warped or delaminated.

That limit defines your inspection. Surface wear a machine can polish out is normal used condition; damage reaching the data layer is a coaster. A disc that has been through a machine many times has thinner plastic and a shorter life, so on a lot, ask whether the discs were resurfaced and pay loose prices for them.

Region codes: will the copy even boot

  • PlayStation and PlayStation 2 discs are locked into three regions: NTSC-U/C for North America, NTSC-J for Japan, PAL for Europe. A US console will not boot a Japanese or European disc without a modchip or a swap disc.
  • PlayStation 3, 4 and 5 game discs are not region locked, so those imports load normally. Add-on content stays tied to the store account region, so a disc can refuse downloadable content bought elsewhere.
  • Xbox One and Xbox Series game discs are not region locked. The same consoles still enforce region codes on DVD and Blu-ray movies.
  • Game Boy, Game Boy Color, Game Boy Advance and standard DS cartridges are not region locked. The 3DS family is locked, and DSi exclusive cards are locked as well.
  • Nintendo Switch game cards are not region locked, with the exception of consoles and cards distributed in China.

When you scan an import, check the price and whether your buyer's console will boot it. Put the region in the listing title: a disclosed import sells, an undisclosed one generates a return.

Sports titles versus RPGs and horror

Annual sports releases are the cheapest games in the room because the roster expires and the print volume was enormous. Madden 2005 on PlayStation 2, read live on 2026-09-28, sits at $3.03 loose and $6.63 complete. The same year's disc, priced across the platforms it shipped on:

PlatformLooseCompleteNew
PlayStation 2$3.03$6.63$19.95
Xbox$2.69$7.99$9.99
GameCube$4.00$6.89$25.78
PlayStation 2, Collector's Edition$6.56$8.50$46.93
Game Boy Advance$7.00$17.43$17.78
Tapwave Zodiac$65.00$91.10$182.00

The pattern is not that sports games are worthless. It is that the same 2005 roster is worth $3.03 on a console that sold millions and $65.00 loose on a handheld almost nobody owned. Platform scarcity beats the age of the game.

The games that hold money have small print runs and an audience that never left. Rule of Rose, a 2006 PlayStation 2 horror title with a modest run and no re-release, trades at $713.38 loose against Silent Hill 2's $134.14 on a console everyone owned. When a niche RPG or horror disc turns up in a dollar bin, check the print edition, the manual and the serial before pricing it as filler. That is where the money hides.

Consoles, bundles and controllers: price it as parts

A console bundle is several products taped together, and price guides list consoles, controllers, cables and memory cards separately. Before paying a bundle price, add up the parts: a first party controller with intact sticks, the correct video cable, the power supply and any memory card the era required.

Then test the failure points. Optical drives on PlayStation, PlayStation 2 and Sega CD machines wear out; a system that plays music CDs but not game discs is a parts unit. Battery compartments corrode and the corrosion travels into the board. Memory card doors and expansion covers are separately priced and constantly missing. Subtract the parts you cannot verify from the asking price. The verified parts are the only ones you are buying.

Grading sealed games

Sealed game grading only makes sense when the sealed value clears the fee by a wide margin. Three services publish rates on their own sites, read live on 2026-09-28:

ServiceTierFee per gameStated turnaround
PSA Video GamesTurbo$49.9930 business days
PSA Video GamesSpeed-Run$69.9915 business days
PSA Video GamesWarp-Zone$124.995 business days
CGC Video GamesStandard, sealed, cartridge only or box only, up to $2,500 value$5075 working days
CGC Video GamesStandard Bulk, 30 game minimum, complete in box not eligible$4575 working days
CGC Video GamesWalkThrough, no value cap$150 plus 2% of fair market value10 working days
Video Game AuthorityRecase, standard size$402 weeks
Video Game AuthorityStandard vintage, standard size$50About 4 months
Video Game AuthorityStandard modern, releases since 2020$40About 4 months
Video Game AuthorityExpress$75About 2 months
Video Game AuthorityPriority$1252 weeks
Video Game AuthorityWalk Through$25048 hours or less

Three details change the arithmetic. CGC adds a $5 handling fee per submission. VGA adds 2% of fair market value above $5,000. PSA adds 1% on items with a maximum insured value of $1,000 to $1,999 and 2% above $2,000, so a valuable sealed game costs more than the tier sticker price. Wata Games, long the dominant sealed grader, was retired into PSA in October 2025, so no new Wata slabs are being produced.

Grading a sealed sports title worth $15 at $49.99 is a donation. Grading a sealed copy with a four figure guide price, like the $1,400.83 Rule of Rose above, is a business decision. The fee is the floor your game has to clear before shipping both ways.

Video game price scanner: your checklist in the aisle

Work the stack in this order.

  1. Read the spine band for print edition and region.
  2. Open the case and confirm the manual and the original art, not a generic replacement.
  3. Tilt the disc under a light for scratches crossing the data tracks.
  4. On cartridges, boot the game, write a save and reload it.
  5. Scan and compare sold listings, never asking prices.

Run the scan with our barcode price checker, which does the same lookup for any category, and read the barcode scanning apps for resellers comparison if you want the wider tool breakdown. The eBay arbitrage scanner on the homepage attaches fee and shipping math to the same scan, which is the number that decides the buy.

Questions resellers ask

How much less is a loose game than a complete one

It depends on the title, and the gap is the whole trade. Guides price loose, complete, box only and manual only separately. On Rule of Rose the loose disc was tracked at $713.38 and complete at $1,072.09, so box and manual add half the value again. Price the row matching the copy in your hand.

Does a dead save battery make a cartridge worthless

No. The game still plays. You lose the old saves and the ability to write new ones until the coin cell is replaced, Buyers treat a disclosed dead battery as a known defect with a cheap repair, not a write off.

Can I play a Japanese PlayStation 2 game on a US console

No. PlayStation and PlayStation 2 discs are region locked into NTSC-U/C, NTSC-J and PAL. PlayStation 3, 4 and 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series and Nintendo Switch are not region locked, so those imports boot normally.

Is a Greatest Hits copy worth less than the black label one

Usually yes, and the sealed market shows it hardest. Sealed Final Fantasy VII black label tracked at $1,406.84 against $164.20 for the Greatest Hits printing, while loose copies of both sat within a few dollars of each other. Check the band on the art and the SLUS or SLES prefix on the disc.

Is it worth grading a sealed game I found

Only when the sealed guide price clears the fee several times over. PSA's cheapest video game tier is $49.99 and CGC's standard tier is $50, so a sealed game worth $20 should be sold raw. A sealed copy with a four figure guide price is a genuine submission.

Contextual Resources